The second of three made-for-TV movies detailing the life of the so-called Long Island "Lethal Lolita" Amy Fisher (played this time by Drew Barrymore) a rebellious, unsure-of-herself 16-year-old girl who became sexually involved with Joey Buttafuoco, a married, 30-something, auto mechanic, in which the unbalanced Fisher planned and shot Buttafuoco's wife in August 1992 in which he may or may not have coerced Fisher into doing the deed, and then denying any involvement with he... (Full plot summary below)
Enjoy FREE movies and series with your Prime (USA) subscription or when you start a 30-day free trial!
| Movie Source | Available | Offers | Added | Views | Quality | Format | Rating | Link | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | UK only | 1 Month Free Trial | 12 May 2021 | 3764 | HD | Watch OnlineStream Instantly | 74% |  Report: Broken Link |   |
| USA only | 1 Month Free Trial | 12 Sep 2014 | 1636 | HD | Watch OnlineStream Instantly | 75% | Report: Broken Link | |
| IRELAND only | 1 Month Free Trial | 01 Jan 2017 | 5615 | HD | Watch OnlineStream Instantly | 68% | Report: Broken Link | |
 | UK only | 30 Day Free Trial | 01 Apr 2013 | 322 | HD | Watch OnlineStream Instantly | 100% | Report: Broken Link | |
![Its HD [The Amy Fisher Story]](/images/logos/icons/itshd.png){kind=icon} | WORLDWIDE | ? | 10 Dec 2015 | 3238 | HD | Watch OnlineStream Instantly | 96% | Report: Broken Link | |
 | UK only | 30 Day Free Trial | 30 Jul 2013 | 212 | HD | Watch OnlineStream Instantly | 47% | Report: Broken Link | |
 | UK only | Free Credit | 03 Oct 2024 | 125 | HD | Watch OnlineStream Instantly | 41% | Report: Broken Link | |
 | WORLDWIDE | ? | 06 Nov 2022 | 114 | HD | Watch OnlineStream Instantly | 29% | Report: Broken Link | |
 | WORLDWIDE | ? | 25 Sep 2013 | 12 | SD / TV | Watch OnlineStream Instantly | 11% | Report: Broken Link | |
 | WORLDWIDE | ? | 16 Jun 2015 | 131 | HD | Watch OnlineStream Instantly | 13% | Report: Broken Link | |
 | WORLDWIDE | ? | 17 Feb 2016 | 18 | SD / TV | Watch OnlineStream Instantly | 6% | Report: Broken Link | |
Links compiled using automated software. Availability of offers subject to change / might be region specific / out of date.
| Movie Source | Available | Offers | Added | Views | Quality | Format | Rating | Link | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| UK only | 30 Day Free Trial | 21 May 2017 | 3326 | SD / DVD | DVD RentalRent by Post | 71% |  Report: Broken Link | |
 | UK only | N/A | 21 May 2017 | 30 | SD / DVD | DVD RentalRent by Post | 41% | Report: Broken Link | |
 | USA only | 1 Month Free Trial | 21 May 2017 | 177 | SD / DVD | DVD RentalRent by Mail | 8% | Report: Broken Link | |
| USA only | 1 Month Free Trial | 21 May 2017 | 12260 | SD / DVD | DVD RentalRent by Mail | 79% | Report: Broken Link | |
| Movie Source | Available | Offers | Added | Views | Quality | Format | Rating | Link | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| UK only | 30 Day Free Trial | 17 Nov 2025 | 292 | HD / BR | Blu Ray RentalRent by Post | 89% | Report: Broken Link | |
| UK only | N/A | 17 Nov 2025 | 39 | HD / BR | Blu Ray RentalRent by Post | 37% | Report: Broken Link | |
| USA only | 1 Month Free Trial | 21 May 2017 | 92 | HD / BR | Blu Ray RentalRent by Mail | 12% | Report: Broken Link | |
| USA only | 1 Month Free Trial | 17 Nov 2025 | 8576 | HD / BR | Blu Ray RentalRent by Mail | 89% | Report: Broken Link | |
The second of three made-for-TV movies detailing the life of the so-called Long Island "Lethal Lolita" Amy Fisher (played this time by Drew Barrymore) a rebellious, unsure-of-herself 16-year-old girl who became sexually involved with Joey Buttafuoco, a married, 30-something, auto mechanic, in which the unbalanced Fisher planned and shot Buttafuoco's wife in August 1992 in which he may or may not have coerced Fisher into doing the deed, and then denying any involvement with her.
Leave your thoughts about The Amy Fisher Story.
| Combustible CelluloidJeffrey M. AndersonThe material may suck you in even as you're laughing at it. |
| User ReviewC.G. Cjesus christ drew barrymore. also "buttafuouco" |
| User ReviewRetro Pamazing!! i love it! drew barrymore is the best on this movie!! |
| User ReviewAdrienne LDrew Barrymore won the ratings war with her performance as Amy Fisher (The Long Island Lolita) back in the early 90's on tv beating Alyssa Milano and some other nameless chick. |
| User ReviewNicholas EThe movie shows us the wrong pespective, we should be hearing about Mary Jo Buttafuoco or at least get to sympathize with her. What the movie gets wrong is that it tries to create a victim out of the Long Island Lolita. Barrymore, though, saves the film with her excellent performance. |
| User ReviewJay BA pretty well done TV movie featuring lots of insight and one of Barrymore's better performances. |
| User ReviewLarry Yanother supermarket DVD 2.99 DVD combo pack purchase |
| User ReviewCandy RDrew's character is obsessed with this married man. Ok thriller. |
| User ReviewMuffin MOn May 19th 1992, 17-year-old high school student Amy Fisher (Drew Barrymore) fired a bullet into the head of Mary Jo Buttafuoco (Laurie Paton), the wife of the bodyshop owner with whom she claimed to have been having a sexual affair. But in the explosive media frenzy that followed, did the truth become the most innocent victim of all? This is the sensational true story of lust, greed and obsession that shocked the nation. also stars Anthony John Denison, Harley Jane Kozak, Ken Angel, Lindsay Bourne, Gary Chalk, Linda Darlow and Garry Davey. directed by Andy Tennant. |
| User ReviewRichard DOf the three Amy Fisher TV movies, this is the one that doesn't take Joey's or Amy's side. I think it really kind of suffers in this regard, lacking a clear purpose and direction. After an entertaining first act that is full of the kind of overheated melodrama you expect from TV exploitation flicks, it really loses focus and just meanders around introducing plot points and characters seemingly at random. Perhaps it just assumes that all viewers will be completely familiar with all the details of the real story ... a fair assumption perhaps in 1993, but not this many years later. |
